(716) 329-4191

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
Cakes by Katya Custom Cakes, Bakery and Cafe in North Tonawanda NY
  • Bakery
  • Menu
  • Place an Order
  • Contact Us

Our Menu

Cakes by Katya Menu September 9, 2025
Cakes by Katya Menu September 9, 2025
Download Menu as PDF

Need Something Custom Made?

In addition to our standard assortment of cakes, we specialize in making custom-designed cakes to help make any celebration special and memorable. Whether you are celebrating a baby shower, birthday, anniversary, graduation, promotion/retirement, or just want to make a holiday a little more special, we can create a custom and delicious cake that is sure to make an impression.

Place An Order

A picture is worth a thousand Mmmms…

Sometimes the best bakery finds happen when you’re Sometimes the best bakery finds happen when you’re searching for something specific. 🥐✨

We loved reading this review from MBS Wellness, who found Cakes by Katya while searching for a particular baked good and decided to stop in.

From the pastry case to the variety and friendly service, we’re so glad the visit made a sweet first impression. And hearing “will definitely be back” might just be our favorite part. 🤍

Thank you for giving Cakes by Katya a try and for sharing such kind words!

#cakesbykatya #buffalobakery #buffaloeats
A small part of the lamination process for my croi A small part of the lamination process for my croissants. 
Roll dough, fold, chill, repeat, cut, chill, shape. 
A process that 100% tries my patience but is 100% worth it. 
#croissants #buffalopastries #buffalobakery
A perfect princess birthday cake for a perfect lit A perfect princess birthday cake for a perfect little girl. 
Towers, roses, gold, butterflies-what could be better?

#princesscake #birthdaycake #buffalocakes #castlecake #twotiercake
Ships ahoy! An ARRRRgh-some birthday cake for a wo Ships ahoy!
An ARRRRgh-some birthday cake for a wonderful little girl! 
#piratecake #birthdaycake #cakes #seacake #buffalocakes
We will be CLOSED September 8th and 9th! We are a We will be CLOSED September 8th and 9th! 
We are also fully booked with specialty cake orders until September 15th. Thank you to everyone!
The kind of bakery find you immediately start tell The kind of bakery find you immediately start telling people about.

MJ has been coming to Cakes by Katya since 2022, and for good reason. In her words, the cakes have that European-style balance, just the right sweetness, rich flavor, and elegant designs. She also called the bakery’s filled croissants some of the best.

The best part? You do not need a special occasion to enjoy Cakes by Katya. Stop by the café for cakes, croissants, sandwiches, cupcakes, and more from the case, or order ahead for whole cakes, dessert trays, and celebration desserts.

Come for a treat. Leave knowing exactly what you want for your next celebration.
📍 3509 Niagara Falls Blvd., near the Wurlitzer building
📞 716-329-4191

#cakesbykatya #wnybakery #buffalodesserts #buffalobakery
Harry Potter + Alice in Wonderland = a magical bir Harry Potter + Alice in Wonderland = a magical birthday cake!
We make cakes for all occasions and themes! 
#cake #birthdaycake #buffalocakes #harrypottercake #aliceinwonderlandcake
Classic white iced wedding cake with fresh flowers Classic white iced wedding cake with fresh flowers. 
10/10 elegant 
100% timeless 
1000% beautiful 

#buffalocakes #buffalowedding #buffaloweddings #weddingcake #threetiercake
They see me rollin’(croissants) They hatin’ (beca They see me rollin’(croissants) 
They hatin’ (because they have to wait) 
Patrollin’ and tryna catch me laminatinggg(my croissants) 

Stop in during store hours for a variety of filled croissants-chocolate, pistachio, almond, raspberry, plain, ham and cheese. We also have cinnamon rolls, danishes, cookies, cheesecake slices, cake slices and so much more! 
#buffalodesserts #croissants #weddingcakes
Wedding season is off to a full swing! Get your we Wedding season is off to a full swing! Get your wedding cake with Cakes by Katya. Modern or classic, we can do both. #weddingcake #weddingcakes #buffaloweddingcake #buffalocakes #fourtiercake
This is what 3 days of work looks like in 60 secon This is what 3 days of work looks like in 60 seconds.
Day one-the dough is mixed and rested overnight to develop flavor from the yeast and to relax the gluten. 
Day two-the dough is laminated in a series of roll/fold/chill steps, then cut and shaped. 
Day three-the croissants are proofed, egg washed, baked, then filled. 

✔️Rolled small batch. 
✔️Stacked layer by layer. 
✔️Cut by hand. 
✔️Chocolate placed by hand. 
✔️Rolled one at a time. 

No short cuts. No frozen dough trucked in.Just butter, flour, time, and a baker who measures everything twice.

Want to see everything we make? 
Comment MENU and we'll send our full menu.

3509 Niagara Falls Blvd, North Tonawanda NY (near the Wurlitzer building)

#BuffaloFoodie #716eats #BuffaloPastry
We’re back to the wedding cake classics with butte We’re back to the wedding cake classics with buttercream piping, frills, pillars and a bride and groom topper! Do we like or do we love it?! #weddingcake #vintagecake #cakedecorating
Follow on Instagram

Contact Us

  • If necessary, you may upload up to (3) photos that accompany your request.
    Drop files here or
    Accepted file types: jpg, gif, png, Max. file size: 64 MB, Max. files: 3.

    Cakes By Katya

    3509 Niagara Falls Blvd
    North Tonawanda, NY 14120

    (716) 329-4191

    Hours

    Tuesday-Friday: 9am – 5pm
    Saturday: 8am – 2pm

    Copyright © 2026. Cakes By Katya. All Rights Reserved.
    • Follow
    • Follow
    • Follow
    • Follow